No Spend Challenges?
![]() |
| Photo pexels.com Tim Douglas |
In tracking my spending this quarter and posting What I Spend,WIS, for 8 weeks, many noticed multiple no spend days. These were happenstance more than intent. I know there's different minds of what no spend challenges mean and if they are an effective budget management tool. I wasn't doing a no spend or low spend challenge, just tracking, but have been thinking about the strategy.
I've read opinions that they just cause delayed spending later, particularly if it's just putting off a purchase. Worse, the deprivation mindset might lead to overspend once the challenge is done. Also, that No Spend challenges can be more expensive as the self imposed closed wallet misses loss leaders or other opportunities to lower cost of living overall. It could mean not getting something fixed when it's minor only to have said item completely die before its time. These are all very valid points.
On the other hand, No Spend challenges force discipline and a use it up, don't waste mentality. It pushes creativity to still enjoy good food, entertainment, and looking nice without having to always purchase something new. Staying out of stores curbs impulse buys and stocking up on items that are already plentiful in the home.
![]() |
| Photo from https://kaboompics.com/ |
I'm going to be sort of a midling on this for the rest of the year. I'll avoid stores if I have no specific need or intent, including online stores. But, I'll buy food to supplement my pantry and freezer, stock regularly used items when on sale, and shop ahead for the holidays. As I've committed to a big vacation and a couple smaller trips, I'll leverage my fun with free and low cost options. This is nothing new to most of you, or to me, but I feel like writing it down supports my resolve.


I agree with your approach: avoid stores if you have no specific need. Good start. A lot of our days here are no spend days by virtue of our household's culture (not the best word, but it works) and the fact that I don't like to shop, period. Not in stores, not online. That makes choices a lot easier!
ReplyDeleteThat really is my best strategy, avoiding stores. I haven't done a lot of looking at ads, but may start doing that more so that Im truly just buying lowest prices and cooking from my pantry and freezer.
DeleteEveryone gets to set the "rules" for their own no or low spend challenge! I think low spend or no spend in certain categories is more honest as we all have to pay our bills and buy food, etc. Limiting the budget for categories like food or gift spending can also be very helpful. Sounds like you have a good plan to spend on what is important to you and within your means.
ReplyDeleteI agree to strategues by category. I'm trying to cut back spending on eating out, but then let my grocery budget be more flexible. I can feed 3-4 at home with the same or similar meals in restaurant so having a friend join me is quite economical for us both.
DeleteI’ve become much less interested in shopping of any sort as I’ve gotten older, which is probably a good thing considering budget constraints.
ReplyDeleteI think your approach is sound, and saving for lovely holidays is great incentive.
Alison in Devon x
I dash in and out...stores are often over stimulating to me and overwhelming visually. Im actually looking forward to the holidays again...it's been a long road to get here.
DeleteI am Blessed to have not been born with the shopping gene. I was however, born with the travel gene so the 2 work well together ;-) Funny quip: Mom used to say "can't you afford a new sweater? You've been wearing that one at least 20 years".....🤣 And I think I've put 80 miles on my car this month. Annual maintenance appt tomorrow but that's close enough it won't hit 100.
ReplyDeleteWhatever method works for you to meet your goals are perfect! Happy Tuesday!
I got that travel gene too. But, even travelling, I get overwhelmed in the various shops, even more so than home. My girls hated a dress I held onto for way too long, but I loved it.
DeleteI don’t do no spend per se, but I do try to have no grocery spend weeks sometimes. The tricky part is keeping ny DH out of Costco. It is his “happy place,” and he tends to overbuy there.
ReplyDeleteDefinitely useful to do no spend groceries occasionally to ensure what I have us used up. I like the forced creativity too and have found a few favorite meals that way. My husband loved Sams Club too. So many deals in super sized packages.
DeleteI am lucky that I want or need very little - so grocery shopping is my one thing. I am not a big shopper at all - so have many no spend days.
ReplyDeleteDo what works well for you - there is no right or wrong way.
I have average wants, but travel is my real want. I'll gladly spend less on day to day to afford trains, planes, and automobiles.
DeleteYou seem to have got this just right for you and that is all that matters. Keeping an eye on things is a good thing, with the flexilbility to change as and when needed.
ReplyDeleteFlexibility is key to managing a set budget. I've 5 years on my current "income" and refuse to increase my retirement withdrawal for inflation, so watching every line item us important. But I want fun, treats for my family, and give to my community, so that motivates me farther.
DeleteI have actually been doing no spend days for a very long time. Now that isn't to say that if something needs fixing, or our vehicle needs an oil change or winter tire change over I would put it off. What I find is that when I plan my meals using what is on hand, I am better able to shop the flyers for sales every two weeks. Bills are paid twice a month in the middle and at the end or close to the end of the month. By staying away from stores I find myself saving more than spending. The last three months of the year are the most costly for us due to insurance payments and such so by having days where we spend nothing it helps us cut costs a bit.
ReplyDeleteGod bless.
What is it about the 4th quarter of the year? I'm glad I think ahead but sadly so many people get caught off guard.
DeleteI've only ever seen very positive things about "no spend" periods, although I think your attitude of not missing deals but not buying non-essentials is the one I'd most likely adopt!
ReplyDeleteIts a principle I've not yet mastered. As I purge, I hate seeing minimally or even non-used items wasting space and money.
DeleteI'm trying really hard to manage our cash flow, which includes of course not making unnecessary purchases. Travel (as another posted above) is driving that, because as the cost for some basics (getting Nick to & from college) increases, it means less available funds for "fun" travel. If I can keep other costs as limited as possible, it frees up extra budget for the fun stuff. As a general rule, I don't shop for fun, although I'm going to Palm Springs with my sister & parents this weekend, and my mom has already asked if we can shop for a few hours if it's raining. Let's hope I'm not tempted by anything. - Hawaii Planner
ReplyDeleteIt wasn't bear the same costs, but even with kids 4-5 hours away, it was expensive going to and from. I don't shop for fun as its very overwhelming...part of why I like Aldi, few choices. Shopping just liss leaders helps my brain too as I can get in and out.
DeleteI don't get myself no spend challenges - they don't seem to work with me, but I do limit myself. I do find that if I don't go out so much, I don't spend. That means meal planning and making lists and working meals from sale items. If I go to the shops for food I end up spending needlessly.
ReplyDeleteI'm going to tighten a few categories of spending through the end of the year to offset the highest quarter expenditures. I really need to be home focused anyway and keep on with purging and clearing rooms. Like you said, if I'm home I'm not spending.
DeleteHi Sam. The value I find in giving thought to No Spend Days, is that it helps to assess whether the urge to spend was an impulse vs a need. I did a No Spend week after reading an interesting book called 'The Ultimate Cheapskate' by Jeff Yeager. He challenges his readers to go a week without spending other than essential, asserting that the average home has enough food on hand to last a week, and enough underutilized entertainment on hand to last a year. His primary premise was that much of many people's spending is to alleviate boredom or satisfy a compulsion.
ReplyDeleteI learned a lot about myself during the week I did it, almost 15 years ago, that still remains with me today.
(His book is very funny as well as informative. I found it a very fast and pleasant read.)
By sheer apathy to really go and about I've probably done a lot of no spend weeks except on necessities. I definitely think he's right.
DeleteKathy from Lendery here. You make a fair point that "It could mean not getting something fixed when it's minor only to have said item completely die before its time." A rigid no spend rule can end up costing more. Your middle path of buying only with a specific need sounds sensible. When a repair is bigger than savings allow, lendery.com, a Vancouver-founded marketplace, lets people compare offers from vetted partner lenders with rate, monthly payment and total cost side by side and no obligation. Enjoy the vacation planning!
ReplyDelete